Open knowledge. Shared progress.Help the exchange grow
Back to article

A tenant who drills cereal rye after harvest spends about $54.40 an acre on a practice that takes several seasons to pay back. In USDA's 2024 land-tenure survey, landlords reported yearly renewal on more than half of the acres they rent to their first-listed tenant. In SARE's cover-crop budget, the acre does not earn a yearly profit until about its third season. The lease conversation is therefore a pricing question: who pays for the early years, and who will be farming the field when the returns arrive?

USDA's 2024 Tenure, Ownership, and Transition of Agricultural Land (TOTAL) survey counted 347.8 million acres rented out, against 528.2 million acres farmed by the people who own them. That puts about 40% of the farmland in the survey under a lease. Non-operating landlords own 79% of the rented acres, and the principal landlords behind them average 69.2 years old. Because 52% of those principal landlords have never farmed, a tenant often makes the case for a cover crop to an owner with no farming experience. NASS TOTAL highlights · NASS briefing

When landlords described the lease with the first tenant they listed, 288.4 million acres in all, the most common term was a single year.

Share of the 288.4 million acres landlords reported for their first-listed tenant. USDA NASS 2024 TOTAL, Quick Stats tenant characteristics.

The relationship usually outlasts the paper. Landlords had rented to the same tenant for 11.6 years on average, and 57% of these acres had been with one tenant for ten years or more. A tenant on an annual lease may well farm long enough to collect on a cover crop, but nothing in the lease promises it. Landowners also told NASS they expect about 43 million acres of farmland to change hands within five years. NASS Quick Stats, tenants · NASS briefing

In SARE's Cover Crop Economics base case for corn, with $37/ac for seed and seeding, no grazing, no payment and normal weather, the cover crop loses $31.36/ac in its first year. Fertilizer savings begin in year three and yield gains keep growing, so the acre earns $1.42 in its third year and $17.90 in its fifth. SARE, Table 4, p. 6

Net return in the first, third and fifth year of use, not a running total. SARE base case: $37/ac seed and seeding, $3.50 corn, normal weather, no grazing or payment. Myers et al. 2019, Table 4.

Because those are single-year returns, the early losses still have to be earned back. If years two and four fall midway between SARE's figures, the running total is still about −$17/ac after five years. Soil organic matter runs on an even longer clock, and SARE notes it can take five years or more to improve noticeably. USDA's Economic Research Service drew the same shape with a hypothetical budget in which cumulative net benefits did not pass zero until year 16, or year 22 once future dollars were discounted at 4%. SARE, p. 23 · ERS ERR-353, p. 21

Lay that curve over a one-year lease and the tenant pays for the worst season while every later gain depends on renewal. Even a five-year lease leaves a tenant without a payment about $17/ac behind in this budget, so the cost split and the exit terms matter as much as the length. An exit clause, covered below, moves the unrecovered cost of a short tenure to the landowner.

The series' cover-crop budget puts cereal rye ahead of soybeans at $54.40/ac, of which $18 is seed. The rest covers custom drilling and a separate spray pass at Iowa State's 2026 survey rates, plus herbicide. Suppose the tenant also receives a $25/ac net cost-share payment and values soybeans at $11 a bushel after the costs that change with yield, as in the cover-crop article. Iowa State 2026 custom rates, pp. 2–3

Dollars per acre in year one. Rye budget and $25 example payment from the series' cover-crop article; the tenant keeps the payment in every row; soybeans valued at $11/bu net.

Sharing the bill cuts the tenant's first-year hurdle from 2.7 bushels to 1.0 when the landowner buys the seed, and to 0.2 under a 50/50 split. If the payment never arrives, a tenant paying everything needs 4.9 bu/ac. The landowner's $27.20 is about a tenth of the $271/ac Iowa average cash rent for 2025, and it can arrive as a rent credit instead of a check. Iowa State C2-21, Table 1

A landowner who pays part of the bill is buying changes that stay with the field after any tenant leaves. SARE's budget credits $2–$4/ac a year for erosion repair the cover crop avoids: the machinery and labor spent filling gullies and cleaning ditches. Across the 23 cover-crop studies in a 2019 meta-analysis, infiltration rates were about 35% higher on average, so more of a heavy rain enters the soil instead of running off. The organic matter gain matures on the owner's timeline rather than an annual tenant's. SARE, Table 4 · Basche and DeLonge 2019

Conservation already running on a field also counts toward future contracts, because CSP requires an operation to already meet NRCS's stewardship threshold for at least two priority resource concerns, and part of each annual payment rewards existing conservation. Landlords reported only about 3% of rented acres enrolled in EQIP, CSP or another conservation program outside CRP in 2024. 7 CFR 1470.20 · 7 CFR 1470.24 · NASS Quick Stats, TOTAL

Most owners are open to the conversation. In American Farmland Trust's 2018–2020 survey of non-operator landowners, 81% of the 323 Iowa respondents said they were comfortable extending their operator's lease to make conservation practical, and 73% were comfortable asking for a lease addendum. The Iowa sample drew equally from women and men and left out trust-held land. AFT, Table 8

A term as long as the payback. Iowa State's conservation lease supplement says a multi-year lease, or a supplement to an annual one, should describe how both parties share the risks and rewards of long-term practices. A flexible cash lease shares a different risk: when rent is a share of gross revenue, any yield effect of the cover crop is split in the same proportion as the revenue. Iowa State C2-08 · Iowa State C2-21

A written cost split. The same supplement advises that a plan for sharing expenses and cost-share payments be part of the lease, with rents adjusted to reflect the costs and risks each party carries. When the split is in writing, it can be proven for as long as the lease runs.

A conservation addendum. The University of Illinois publishes a Soil Health and Conservation Addendum that covers tillage and cover crops, offers optional rent adjustments and attaches to either a fixed cash or a crop-share lease. Iowa State's supplement takes a checklist approach, with lines such as seeding a cover crop on agreed acres and no-till on designated fields. Drake University's Agricultural Law Center published a longer landowner's guide in 2010. farmdoc conservation addendums · Iowa State C2-08 · Drake guide

An exit price. Iowa State's improvements supplement observes that tenants are unlikely to invest without assured repayment of the unexhausted value if they leave. For permanent structures such as terraces or waterways, the conservation supplement deducts any cost share and depreciates the rest at 5–10% a year. A tenant who leaves three years into a 10% schedule is owed 70% of the net cost. A cover crop is closer to lime, which Iowa State spreads over three to five years, so the parties can allocate each season's cover-crop cost over an agreed number of years and refund the unused share. An Iowa appeals court enforced that kind of clause in Hettinger v. City of Strawberry Point (2016), where a lease amendment spread lime over seven years, and sent the case back to set damages. Iowa State C2-07 · Iowa State C2-08 · ISU CALT case summary

Tenants can enroll rented ground in EQIP and CSP as long as the lease covers the contract, under the rules in force in November 2026.

7 CFR parts 1466 (EQIP) and 1470 (CSP); NRCS-CPA-1200 (December 2025) and the EQIP and CSP contract appendices.

NRCS's conservation program application requires written authorization from the landowner to install structural or vegetative practices on leased land, and the contract terms name form NRCS-CPA-1257 or another written concurrence, provided on request. If the field office cannot confirm whether a cover crop falls under that rule, get the authorization anyway. Losing the lease midway has its own price. The tenant must notify NRCS, which can end the contract and require some or all of the payments back unless it approves a transfer to a new producer who takes the contract on. EQIP rules · EQIP transfers · CSP rules · CSP transfers · NRCS-CPA-1200 · EQIP contract appendix

A winter cover may protect the owner’s topsoil while its seed bill lands with the tenant. A water buyer adds a third interest. It may need field records for several drainage seasons, including a year when someone else farms the parcel. Agree who can share the planting record, who is authorized to sign and how either party will handle a change of operator before promising those acres.

  • A budget for years one through five, built from seed and custom-work quotes, lease terms and the timing of any reimbursement.
  • A proposed split in dollars per acre, and whether the landowner's share comes as a check or a rent credit.
  • A lease term at least as long as any NRCS contract you plan to sign.
  • The NRCS paperwork: a written lease, plus the landowner's written authorization (NRCS-CPA-1257 or a letter) for any practice the field office cannot confirm is outside the rule.
  • An exit clause stating what the landowner repays, and over how many years each season's cost is spread, if the lease ends early.
  • A baseline soil test with organic matter, so both of you can see what the field gained when the lease comes up again.

Iowa Learning Farms publishes talking points for landowners (Talking With Your Tenant) and a companion series for tenants (Talking With Your Landlord). Pick one field you both care about, price it together, and settle the split before the seed order goes in.

Take the proposed lease term to EQIP or CSP with the field map. EQIP may support a particular installation or management change. CSP’s five-year contract supports stewardship across the operation. Ask the field office which party must document control and sign, then put the agreed split of costs and payments in the lease. The local options are listed under soil-health funding.

A lease renewal is a good time to ask who can afford to keep a practice going. The tenant may have paid for seed, the owner may inherit better ground, and someone downstream may benefit from cleaner water. Putting names, dates and the right to share records on paper gives the person doing the work a way to participate in that value.

  1. USDA NASS, 2024 TOTAL Highlights (ACH22-28), March 2026https://www.nass.usda.gov/sites/default/files/publications/Highlights/2026/TOTAL24.pdf
  2. USDA NASS, 2024 TOTAL executive briefing, March 12, 2026https://www.nass.usda.gov/sites/default/files/Newsroom/Executive_Briefings/2026/03-12-2026.pdf
  3. USDA NASS Quick Stats, 2024 TOTAL tenant characteristicshttps://quickstats.nass.usda.gov/results/D4CFA4FA-3197-3341-9F65-954880381747
  4. USDA NASS Quick Stats, 2024 TOTAL all datahttps://quickstats.nass.usda.gov/results/09A3A8CC-594C-38FD-AC61-6D49C5152F3B
  5. Myers, Weber and Tellatin 2019, SARE *Cover Crop Economics*https://www.sare.org/resources/cover-crop-economics/
  6. Bowman et al. 2025, USDA ERS ERR-353https://www.ers.usda.gov/sites/default/files/_laserfiche/publications/112841/ERR-353.pdf
  7. Iowa State 2026 Iowa Farm Custom Rate Surveyhttps://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/crops/pdf/a3-10.pdf
  8. Basche and DeLonge 2019, *PLoS ONE* 14:e0215702https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215702
  9. Petrzelka et al. 2020, American Farmland Trust Non-Operator Landowner Survey multi-state reporthttps://farmlandinfo.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2021/01/AFT-NOLs-MultiState_1_21-web.pdf
  10. Iowa State Ag Decision Maker C2-21, Flexible Farm Lease Agreementshttps://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/wholefarm/html/c2-21.html
  11. Iowa State Ag Decision Maker C2-08, Lease Supplement for Obtaining Conservation Practiceshttps://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/wholefarm/html/c2-08.html
  12. Iowa State Ag Decision Maker C2-07, Lease Supplement for Investing in Improvementshttps://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/wholefarm/html/c2-07.html
  13. University of Illinois farmdoc, conservation addendums for farm leaseshttps://farmdoc.illinois.edu/agricultural-law
  14. Coppess and Schnitkey 2019, farmdoc dailyhttps://farmdocdaily.illinois.edu/2019/10/conservation-addendums-for-illinois-farm-leases.html
  15. Cox 2010, Drake University Agricultural Law Center, The Landowner's Guide to Sustainable Farm Leasinghttps://farmlandinfo.org/publications/the-landowners-guide-to-sustainable-farm-leasing/
  16. Hettinger v. City of Strawberry Point, Iowa Ct. App. No. 15-0610 (2016), ISU CALT summaryhttps://www.calt.iastate.edu/post/farm-tenant-entitled-recoup-unused-lime-costs
  17. 7 CFR 1466.6, EQIP program requirementshttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1466.6
  18. 7 CFR 1466.21, EQIP contract termshttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1466.21
  19. 7 CFR 1466.25, EQIP contract transfershttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1466.25
  20. 7 CFR 1470.3 and 1470.6, CSP definitions and eligibilityhttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1470.6
  21. 7 CFR 1470.20, CSP stewardship thresholdhttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1470.20
  22. 7 CFR 1470.21, CSP contract termshttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1470.21
  23. 7 CFR 1470.24, CSP paymentshttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1470.24
  24. 7 CFR 1470.25, CSP contract transfershttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-7/section-1470.25
  25. NRCS-CPA-1200 Conservation Program Application, December 2025https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2026-01/NRCS-CPA-1200%20Conservation%20Program%20Application..pdf
  26. NRCS-CPA-1202 Appendix, EQIP general contract provisions, November 2024https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2024-11/NRCS-CPA-1202%20Appendix%20EQIP%20Nov%202024.pdf
  27. CSP contract appendix, December 2025https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2026-03/CSP%201202%20Appendix%20December%202025%201_0.pdf
  28. Iowa Learning Farms, Talking With Your Tenant serieshttps://www.iowalearningfarms.org/resources/talking-with-your-tenant-series
  29. Iowa Learning Farms, Talking With Your Landlord serieshttps://www.iowalearningfarms.org/resources/talking-with-your-landlord-series
  30. EQIPhttps://www.nrcs.usda.gov/programs-initiatives/eqip-environmental-quality-incentives
  31. CSPhttps://www.nrcs.usda.gov/programs-initiatives/conservation-stewardship-program

Soil Health Exchange Team (2026). Who pays for a $54 cover crop on rented ground, and who collects?. Soil Health Exchange. https://soilhealthexchange.com/blog/soil-health-rented-land-economics

Canonical URL: https://soilhealthexchange.com/blog/soil-health-rented-land-economics