The Economics of Regenerative Farming
A farmer pays for seed this fall. A town downstream may benefit from cleaner water for years. Who pays the farmer for that part of the work? Across ten farm decisions, we follow the return a grower can count today and the value we’re building TerraValue to account for.
Start with the evidence on farm profit →
Read the whole series
Choose the decision you face. Each article follows the farm costs, what the research measured and programs that can help pay for the work.
- Part 1Does regenerative farming pay, and how soon?
- Part 2How many bushels can no-till give up and still pay?
- Part 3What does a cover crop need to earn back?
- Part 4The same tanker of manure can save $20 an acre or cost $34
- Part 5How many days do the cows have to graze for the fence to pay?
- Part 6What does an oat year have to earn to keep up with corn and soybeans?
- Part 7Who pays for a $54 cover crop on rented ground, and who collects?
- Part 8What is a better bad year worth per acre?
- Part 9How many extra AUMs does a paddock-and-water plan need to pay?
- Part 10What is one more point of organic matter worth per acre?
Where funding fits
A seed grant can carry the first season. A longer agreement might pay for what changes in the water. When a practice fits your field, the Funding Finder can help you look for support by state and practice. Save a promising program in My Farm.
Why we’re building TerraValue
A farmer who buys less feed sees the saving on the next invoice. If that same grazing plan protects nesting cover or keeps soil out of a stream, the farm may have no buyer for either service. A grant can help install the fence. What will pay for the years of stewardship that follow?
We’re building TerraValue to help establish a broader market for agricultural ecosystem services. Carbon is one part. Cleaner water, soil retained, water available through a dry spell and habitat each have their own beneficiaries and measures. Our aim is to account for those outcomes together, show where the evidence is strong enough to support a claim, and find out who would pay the steward for delivering it.
Our team approaches that work from three directions. Soil Health Exchange looks at the research and the farm return. FieldLog helps growers keep dates, costs and observations with the field. In TerraValue we’re developing the link between a baseline, repeated measurements and a payment a grower could earn. The test is what reaches the farm after the cost of the practice, monitoring and verification. How the platforms fit together.
What the field studies measured
- No-till
- About 25% less soil lost in surface runoff
In a 16-year small-watershed comparison with chisel tillage, no-till reduced sediment loss while dissolved phosphorus increased. Measure both at the field outlet. Shipitalo et al. · Soil and nutrients in runoff over 16 crop years
- Cover crops
- 62% less nitrate load in tile drainage
A four-year trial compared winter rye with no cover in a no-till corn–soybean rotation. At a new site, sample nitrate and measure how much water drains to estimate pounds lost. Kaspar et al. · Rye and nitrate loss in tile drainage
- Manure management
- Surface phosphorus losses differed in one of four years
Shallow disk injection reduced annual total phosphorus in surface runoff in the year with a detectable difference. Measure losses across storms and application seasons. Jahanzad et al. · Dairy manure placement and phosphorus runoff
- Integrated crop–livestock
- 57% lower spring nitrate concentration under corn
At Iowa’s Marsden Farm, longer rotations used forage legumes and occasional cattle manure. The spring drainage-water result compares whole rotations. A buyer paying by the pound would also need the water volume. Iowa State University · Marsden Farm long-term rotation study
How those outcomes can be priced
Water quality and nutrient trading
Start with the pounds of nitrogen or phosphorus a program accepts at its accounting point. A utility can compare the delivered reduction with its cost of removing that load. The 2026 Conowingo pay-for-success award for conservation tillage, cover crops and manure management budgeted about $14 per pound of estimated nitrogen reduction over five years. Payment depends on verification under that program. Susquehanna River Basin Commission
Crop insurance and resilience
An insurer can compare how often the same kind of acre has an insured loss and what it pays on those claims. If the annual chance fell from 2% to 1% and a loss paid $200 per affected acre, the expected claims cost would fall by $2 per insured acre per year. Testing it would take several seasons of exposure and claims data, with comparisons by crop, soil, weather and coverage. NC State on prevented planting losses
Food and ingredient purchasing
PepsiCo and Cargill are working with Practical Farmers of Iowa to help pay for practice changes on farms that supply them with corn. A consumer packaged goods (CPG) company can document enrolled acres with field and planting records. To claim lower emissions per ton of grain, it also needs a baseline, an emissions estimate and a way to trace the grain. PepsiCo and Cargill’s Iowa partnership
Natural-capital investment
Price eligible habitat acres or verified net metric tons of CO₂e at the contracted rate. Compare the cost of establishing the practice with the discounted stream of payments after monitoring and upkeep. Set who bears the risk if an outcome falls short. In 2025, New York City committed up to $35 million for farm conservation practices as part of its ten-year watershed contracts. Watershed Agricultural Council and New York City DEP
What makes an outcome worth buying?
An acre of rye is straightforward to document. A pound of nitrogen kept out of drinking water takes more work. Before a buyer and grower settle on a price, they need to agree on a few things.
- An outcome counted where it matters
Pounds of nitrate at a utility intake, tons of sediment kept out of a reservoir, an insured loss that never happens. The field result has to reach the place where it changes the payer’s cost.
- A baseline
The same field farmed the old way, and what would have happened without the payment. Every budget in this series compares two ways of farming the same field for that reason.
- Evidence at a cost it can carry
Practice records, models, soil sampling or edge-of-field measurement. Each step adds confidence and cost, so the payer chooses the level it will accept.
- A price that beats the alternative
The treatment, dredging, claim or supply cost the outcome avoids, or the program rate it would replace.
- A payment that changes the farm decision
In the cover-crop budget, a $25 payment still leaves the example rye $29.40 an acre short, and the water-contract example breaks even at $13.28 per accepted pound. A payment smaller than the field’s gap rarely changes what gets planted.
- Duration and shortfall risk
How many years the agreement runs, what happens after a drought or a failed stand, and who holds the reserve.
- Clear claims
Who owns each unit and which programs can stack on the same acre, so one outcome is not sold twice.
- Farmer consent
Which records a farmer shares, with whom and for how long.
How Soil Health Exchange helps today
- Farm accounts and field trials that show what growers spent, what they earned and which costs a payment could cover.
- Plain explanations that reach farmers and the advisers they work with, backed by an expert network in soil science, extension and agronomy.
- CEMA 216 sampling plans, lab results and field records that farmers keep in My Farm and choose whether to share.
- The Funding Finder, which tracks programs that pay for practices and outcomes.
What TerraValue is developing
- A field model that compares a practice with the same field’s baseline on its own soil and climate, with modeled estimates kept apart from measurements.
- An outcome record of who can claim each unit, so one result can inform several decisions without being sold twice.
- A proposed ecosystem dividend: a recurring payment to the steward when a beneficiary funds an agreed outcome.
TerraValue, built by the same team as Soil Health Exchange, is in development and makes no payments today. It is looking for the payers and pilot partners who would set those terms.
What the working paper models
TerraValue’s working paper models cover crops, no-till and better-matched nitrogen rates on a tile-drained Corn Belt acre. At its base prices, the reference value is $65.98 per acre per year, including $47.38 for reduced nitrate loss. Under the paper’s proposed sampled-evidence rule, a steward would receive $42.22 per acre per year after reserve and administration allowances.
These are modeled proposals for discussion, not offers. Turning one into income would take a payer that agrees on the baseline, the eligible units, the evidence, the price and the payment schedule. Fuel, feed and fertilizer savings already in the farm budget stay there, counted once.
Modeled annual payment by level of evidence
| Comparison | $/acre |
|---|---|
| Modeled · 60% | +$31.67 |
| Modeled + sampled · 80% | +$42.22 |
| Measured · 95% | +$50.14 |
What would make a stewardship outcome worth paying for?
We would love to hear about one real decision. If you buy an agricultural practice or outcome, what do you pay for, in what units, and what evidence do you trust? If you farm or monitor fields, which benefit do you see going uncounted, and what would it cost to document it? An example from a crop insurance policy, a food ingredient purchase or a single field can help shape TerraValue.
Prefer email? Write to contact@soilhealthexchange.com. Read how TerraValue approaches field value