Open knowledge. Shared progress.Help the exchange grow
The Journal

Part 8 · The Economics of Regenerative Farming

What is a better bad year worth per acre?

Price the bad year as well as the average. See what a shallower or rarer loss year is worth, what the drought and wet-spring evidence shows and which insurance rules apply.

SH
By Soil Health Exchange Team||Updated |11 min read|10 reads
Print / Save PDF
A young soybean plant emerges through dry wheat stubble above a cross-section of dark soil.
A soybean plant grows through winter wheat stubble in a long-term no-till rotation in South Dakota. — Credit: Colette Kessler / USDA NRCS South Dakota
This article ends with a Knowledge Check — 8 randomized questions from a 8-question pool. Score 85% to earn a Certificate of Completion.

Suppose a dry summer takes 40 bushels an acre off a corn field one year in four. At the 2026 crop insurance projected price of $4.62/bu, that pattern costs the field $46.20 an acre a year on average. If better soil and management make the loss one year in five instead, the average falls to $36.96, which makes the better bad year worth about $9 an acre, every year. farmdoc daily on 2026 projected prices

That figure is an average, and no farm lives on averages. In the year itself, $184.80 an acre goes missing at once, so a budget that prices the downside needs a second number for how wide the swing runs.

Price the bad year as well as the average

The arithmetic takes two inputs: what a loss year costs and how often it comes. Multiply them and you have the expected cost per acre per year. Over 20 seasons, one year in four means five loss years and one in five means four, so the missing loss year works out to $184.80 spread across 20 seasons, the same $9.24 an acre. The table keeps corn at $4.62 and adds a shallower loss of 30 bushels.

The expected cost of a bad year

Loss in the bad yearHow oftenAverage cost per acre per yearSaving vs. first rowYear-to-year spread
40 bu/ac ($184.80)1 year in 4$46.20—$80
40 bu/ac ($184.80)1 year in 5$36.96$9.24$74
30 bu/ac ($138.60)1 year in 4$34.65$11.55$60
30 bu/ac ($138.60)1 year in 5$27.72$18.48$55

Illustrative example at the 2026 corn projected price of $4.62/bu. The spread is the standard deviation of the annual loss.

The spread column measures how far a typical year sits from the average, and it shows what the averages hide. Making the bad year rarer narrows the swing by about $6 an acre, but making it shallower narrows it by about $20. A farm short on working capital may value the shallower loss more than the averages suggest, because the worst year is the one the operating loan has to carry.

Who carries the loss matters just as much. Revenue Protection insures 50 to 75% of a farm's average yield, up to 85% in some areas, valued at the greater of the projected or harvest price. Insure this field at 75% of a 200-bushel average and the policy pays only when yield falls below 150 bushels, so with a steady price both the 40- and 30-bushel losses fall inside the deductible. Moderate bad years belong to the farm, while the insurer's money moves only in the deep ones. USDA Risk Management Agency on Revenue Protection

Soil organic matter shows up in the worst summers

The strongest drought evidence comes from Kane and colleagues, who matched soil organic matter with corn yields and crop insurance records across 754 mostly rain-fed counties from 2000 to 2016. Across those 12,376 county-years, the payoff grew with the severity of the drought. In the driest class of summers, each additional percentage point of organic matter went with about 2.2 Mg/ha more corn, roughly 35 bu/ac, and a 36% smaller share of insured liability paid out for drought. In moderate drought the yield association was about a third as large, at 0.76 Mg/ha (12 bu/ac). Kane et al. 2021, sections 3.1 and 3.2

Drought payouts and soil organic matter

Summer drought classCounty-yearsPayout share per +1% organic matter
Moderate3,9984% lower
Severe1,5378.4% lower
Very severe41036% lower

Payout share is loss cost, drought indemnities divided by insured liability, in rain-fed corn counties, 2000–2016. Kane et al. 2021, section 3.2 and Table 1.

The shape of that gradient is the economic point. The association was strongest in the 410 driest county-years, about 3% of the record, which is why a comparison of average yields can understate what organic matter is worth in the year that hurts. The study compares counties, not fields, and shows association rather than cause. Its authors add that the organic matter gains cover crops or reduced tillage often achieve are smaller than the county-to-county range they studied, and the link weakened on high-clay soils. A four-state county study covering 2000 to 2014 likewise found that soil water-holding capacity steadied corn yields, so both point to soil as a buffer that your own field records can size. Kane et al. 2021, sections 3.1 and 3.4 · Williams et al. 2016

Cover crops trade a wet-spring risk for a dry-spring one

Prevented planting is the other kind of bad year, and there the evidence favors cover crops. Using satellite records from more than 100,000 fields, Lobell and colleagues estimated that cover-cropped fields were only half as likely to go unplanted in the wet spring of 2019. The same study found that cover crops delayed planting by about 4 days for corn and 2.5 days for soybeans, and concluded that they lower some risks in wet conditions but raise them in dry ones. Lobell et al. 2025

County insurance records point the same way. Won and colleagues combined satellite cover-crop maps with 2005–16 crop insurance data from 12 Corn Belt states and found that counties with more cover crops had smaller prevented-planting losses, with a larger reduction after several years of use. In NC State's summary of the study, a 1% rise in adoption translated to nearly $40 million less in prevented-planting indemnities. Won et al. 2023 · NC State summary

On the farm, a prevented-planting payment is meant to cover pre-planting costs, not the crop's margin, so a field that gets planted on time keeps value a claim would not have paid. The dry side of the trade belongs in the same budget, because a cover that draws down spring moisture can make a dry year worse, and the cover-crop budget prices the yield and planting-date side of it. USDA Risk Management Agency on prevented planting

Keep the policy and the practice in step

Since the 2020 crop year, insurance attaches when the cash crop is planted, whether or not the cover was terminated by the guidelines. If an insurer questions a claim, it judges cover-crop management under the same Good Farming Practice rules it applies to seeding rates or fertilizer. The NRCS Cover Crop Termination Guidelines give up-front assurance that a termination date will pass that review. Version 4, dated June 2019, is still the version linked from RMA's cover-crop questions page as of November 2026, and it sets four zones for non-irrigated cropland:

  • Zone 1: terminate at least 35 days before planting a late-spring to fall-seeded crop.
  • Zone 2: terminate at least 15 days before planting that crop.
  • Zone 3: terminate at or before planting.
  • Zone 4: terminate before the crop emerges.

No-till systems may delay termination up to 7 days past the zone deadline, and a fall-seeded cover ahead of a crop planted before March 20 may be terminated as late as planting. When a system falls outside the zones, published university guidance or written support from an agricultural expert can establish it as a good farming practice instead. NRCS Cover Crop Termination Guidelines, Version 4 · RMA cover crop questions

Two rules move money directly. If a cover crop seeded into a standing insured crop damages it, that damage is an uninsured cause of loss and is appraised out of any claim. On prevented-planting acres, a cover crop can be hayed, grazed or cut for silage at any time from the 2021 crop year on without reducing the payment, although harvesting it for grain or seed still does. For a farm with cattle, that turns a lost season into feed. RMA Cover Crops and Crop Insurance fact sheet · RMA Manager's Bulletin MGR-21-004

A $5 discount, on acres with no other payment

The federal Pandemic Cover Crop Program paid $5 an acre toward the premium, capped at the premium owed, for the 2021 and 2022 crop years only, and its farmers.gov page is now archived. In 2026 the benefit comes from state programs run with RMA, each worth up to $5 an acre on the following year's premium and each closed to acres that receive other state or federal cover-crop cost share. RMA Pandemic Cover Crop Program fact sheet · USDA ERS ERR-353, p. 5

State cover-crop premium discounts

StateCover crops and insured cropSign-upLimits
IllinoisSeeded fall 2026, insured crop 2027Pre-enrollment Nov. 30, 2026; applications Dec. 15, 2026–Jan. 15, 2027Up to 190,000 acres statewide, first come, first served; no per-farm cap
WisconsinPlanted 2026, insurable crop 2027Dec. 1, 2026–Jan. 31, 2027, or until funds run out$800,000, or 160,000 acres, a year, first come, first served; no per-applicant cap
IowaSeeded fall 2026, 2027 premiumsDec. 1, 2026–Jan. 22, 2027No acre cap; Whole-Farm Revenue Protection and written-agreement policies may be excluded
IndianaSeeded fall 2025, 2026 cash cropFunding capacity reached for 2026; next round not yet announced750 acres per insurance ID; field must lie in an eligible watershed

Checked on each state's program page November 17, 2026. All four pay up to $5/ac and exclude acres with other state or federal cover-crop incentives.

Five dollars is small next to the $9 to $18 an acre that the worked example puts on a better bad year, but it is the one line that arrives whatever the weather. Because the discount cannot sit on an acre already in a cost-share contract, it fits best on the acres beyond that contract. Illinois Department of Agriculture · Wisconsin DATCP · Iowa Department of Agriculture and Land Stewardship · Indiana State Department of Agriculture

More enterprises can mean a wider swing

A more diverse farm does not automatically have a narrower spread. Poffenbarger and colleagues budgeted four modeled systems on a 1,000-acre (405-ha) central Iowa parcel over 2008–15, and the two systems with cattle matched the cash-crop systems' average returns to land and management. Their returns varied more from year to year, however, and their total costs, excluding land and management, ran four to nine times as high. Cattle bring feed and livestock prices into the budget along with the weather, so the integrated crop–livestock budget needs its own downside line. Poffenbarger et al. 2017

USDA's Economic Research Service drew a similar lesson for cover crops in its 2025 review, finding no consensus among researchers on whether cover cropping raises or lowers net risk, and few studies that test it directly. Until that research catches up, your own records are the best test available. USDA ERS ERR-353, pp. 22–23

Who gets paid for a better bad year

The farm keeps the value of shallower losses inside its deductible. Savings on deep losses, such as the 36% smaller payout share per point of organic matter in Kane's driest summers, go first to the insurance pool. A farm shares in them only through a premium discount or an agreement that pays for a measured outcome. An insurer could test the difference by comparing claim frequency and severity on similar insured acres through several wet and dry years, matching crop, coverage and weather. A food company might value fewer supply interruptions from the same region, which it would track through deliveries.

Records that make a resilience claim testable

A resilience claim can be tested only with bad-year records, and most farms already keep the raw material:

  • the planting date for each field, along with the first day it was fit to plant, so the cost of a wet spring shows up;
  • the cover-crop termination date and method, matched to your NRCS zone, plus the seed tags and FSA-578 report that most state discounts require;
  • prevented-planting acres and the claim paid, by field and year;
  • yield by field in the dry years, from the yield monitor or scale tickets, alongside a soil test that reports organic matter.

The first calculation needs nothing new. Take the worst season of the last ten, set each field's yield that year against its average and price the gap at $4.62. That gap is your loss year, and the number of seasons like it in the decade is your frequency. After the next dry summer, the same comparison will show whether the fields you have been building lose less.

Where to look for assistance

Iowa’s Crop Insurance Discount Program applies an eligible cover-crop incentive to the following year’s premium. For farmers whose immediate cost is seed and planting, EQIP offers a separate practice-support route. Map the acres against the overlap rules above before treating either as income. Other soil-health funding may fit fields outside Iowa.

A steadier harvest can matter to a farm long before an insurer has enough comparable seasons to price that difference. The farmer can track the loss inside the deductible now. To carry the rest into an insurance decision, someone needs to define the comparison and keep the record through ordinary years as well as disasters. If you work with claims or measure farm risk, tell TerraValue what evidence would change that decision.

Keep field ideas coming.

Get the free newsletter: soil health ideas, field answers, and funding opportunities.

Test Your Knowledge

Score 85% or higher to earn a Certificate of Completion.

  1. 1.A dry year takes 40 bu/ac off a corn field. At $4.62/bu, what is it worth per acre per year if that loss comes one year in five instead of one year in four?

  2. 2.In the worked example, which change narrows the year-to-year spread of losses more?

  3. 3.A field averages 200 bu/ac and carries Revenue Protection at 75% coverage. With a steady price, who bears a 40-bushel drought loss?

  4. 4.Kane et al. (2021) found that in the driest summers each extra point of soil organic matter went with about 35 bu/ac more corn and 36% lower drought payouts. How should an adviser use that result?

  5. 5.Why can a comparison of average yields understate what soil organic matter is worth?

  6. 6.Lobell et al. (2025) found cover-cropped fields were half as likely to go unplanted in the wet spring of 2019. What belongs in a cover-crop risk budget as a result?

  7. 7.Since the 2020 crop year, what happens if a farmer terminates a cover crop later than the NRCS zone guidance suggests?

  8. 8.A farmer with 320 acres of cover crops has 160 of them in an EQIP contract and wants a state premium discount. Which acres can enroll?

SH

Written by

Soil Health Exchange Team

#Risk Management#Crop Insurance#Drought Resilience#Cover Crops#Soil Organic Matter#Farm Economics

Scholarly record

References & Citation

Source material for every claim in this article, plus a citation-ready record for reference managers and scholarly indexes.

Cite this

Reference this work

SHE-ART-2026-0114

Soil Health Exchange Team (2026). What is a better bad year worth per acre?. Soil Health Exchange. SHE-ART-2026-0114. https://soilhealthexchange.com/cite/SHE-ART-2026-0114

Stable link →

Soil Health Exchange assigns a stable identifier to every published answer and article. Citations keep working even if the URL changes later.

Sources (21)Show sources
Cite this articleShow formats

Cite this article

Citation-ready record

APA

Soil Health Exchange Team (2026). What is a better bad year worth per acre?. Soil Health Exchange. https://soilhealthexchange.com/blog/soil-health-drought-risk-insurance-economics

More citation formats

MLA

Soil Health Exchange Team. "What is a better bad year worth per acre?." Soil Health Exchange, 2026-11-17, https://soilhealthexchange.com/blog/soil-health-drought-risk-insurance-economics.

Chicago

Soil Health Exchange Team. "What is a better bad year worth per acre?." Soil Health Exchange. Published 2026-11-17. https://soilhealthexchange.com/blog/soil-health-drought-risk-insurance-economics.

Citation metadata is provided for discovery tools and reference managers. Inclusion in external scholarly indexes is not guaranteed.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Continue reading

All articles →

From this series

The Economics of Regenerative Farming